Tuesday, 9 August 2011
Did The American People Lose Their Triple-A Credit Rating or Was It Stolen?
When I was a boy, if I went home to my Mum saying I'd lost something, she'd ask, "Where did you leave it? When did you last see it? Think back! What were you doing at the time?"
"A couple of big boys said they'd look after it for me, and then they started playing Pig-in-the-Middle with me."
"Get right back out there and take it back off them then!"
"They keep throwing it over my head, and telling me to jump higher."
"Why didn't you report it to teacher?"
"Teacher says they're too big to discipline."
"Where is it now? Do they still have it?"
"Yes, they say I can have it back, if I give them my dinner money
every day until - forever."
"That's extortion!" "You haven't lost it! They stole it!
I agree with Mum. I think there's a difference between losing something and extortion, and I think we ought to take account of that before we chastise ourselves or let anyone else tell us that that's what we ought to do.
Besides, if we let people take something from us because they said they would do the right thing and that it was the 'only way', and we trusted them, our wisdom might be in question, but not necessarily our honesty. If they say we must jump higher, or they'll give it to those who can jump higher than we can, we might be unwise to go along with a game that neither our competitors nor we can possibly win. Maybe we should've known that they were beyond the pale - but that doesn't make us responsible for their behaviour. However, we do have a responsibility to learn from the experience and to do our utmost to redress the situation for the benefit of future generations and out of respect for previous generations who struggled so hard, to benefit us.
UK politician Tony Benn spoke the following words in The House of Commons in the early 90s. He was one of the few who never sold out on his principles, even after the majority of his colleagues and party members in the UK Parliamentary Labour Party did, abandoning much of the founding principles - just to ingratiate themselves with an unelected clique, who held the strings to their puppet power:
"These are assets built up by the labour of those who work in (electricity) and by the tax payer who put the equipment in. Now to be auctioned off at half their price, to make a profit, for a tax cut for the rich, before the next election comes. If these were local councillors, they would be before the courts for wilful misconduct. And because they are ministers and then some of them later go on the boards of the companies they've privatised, they are treated as businessmen who know better how to handle it as members of the Board of Directors than allegedly they did as ministers responsible."
However, parliament is there to make the laws, and it was by that means that much of those assets were "taken" - but not lost.
For how can anything be lost when everyone knows where it is? It's all there - all stashed away in the tax havens, because decent ordinary people wanted to trust those whom they chose as their lawmakers and representatives. That trust now seems the greatest loss of all. Yet even that trust wasn't 'lost'. It too, was taken - from our culture - and now, we have to replace it.
In The House of Commons, one doesn't accuse Honourable, and Right Honourable Ladies and Gentlemen of stealing.
This is Tony Benn again: "What's really happened is that after ten years when people have taken things they should never have taken, there is a return of self-confidence and hope..."
(Tony Benn - Pit Closures) http://wn.com/Tony_Benn_-_The_issue_is_Thatcher
Most ordinary people I know just want to play their small part in society and have fair remuneration, for their contribution to that society. They want to trust the people whom they choose as their leaders. That might be naive and unwise; you might call it lazy and complacent - but it's what most of us do. Moreover, we get great comfort from that trust and belief in others. Its absence impoverishes us as a society and as human beings, because it enhances our lives in many ways that financial wealth never can.
We might've been short-sighted, we might have made mistakes and misplaced our trust, but 'we, the people', are not the perpetrators of the theft. Our compliance did not make us complicit in that theft, and as long as we remember our responsibility to future and past generations there's still hope. We might have to replace the stolen assets, as only 'we, the people' can - for the wealth of a community, society or nation always builds on the backs of the majority.
Yet, has anyone noticed recently that, when you finger the real culprits - those "who have taken things they should never have taken" - more and more people are willing to listen? I have. I've found that people are listening now. Now they see it. More and more of them do - and that tells me that there is hope. Perhaps, all that's missing now is the audacity.
Did The American People Lose Their Triple-A Rating